Key Metrics to Look for When Analyzing an SEO Agency

Choosing the right SEO agency can feel overwhelming. With so many companies promising "guaranteed rankings" and "fast results," how do you separate the real experts from those just trying to lock you into a long-term contract?

The truth is, not all SEO agencies are created equal. Some drive real organic growth, while others rely on vanity metrics that look good on paper but don’t actually impact your bottom line.

So how do you know if an SEO agency is worth your investment? The answer lies in key SEO metrics - hard data that reveals whether an agency is truly effective.

In this guide, we’ll break down the most important SEO metrics you should analyze before hiring an agency. By the end, you’ll know exactly what to look for, what questions to ask, and how to avoid getting stuck with the wrong team.

Introduction to Key SEO Metrics

SEO metrics are the numbers that show how well a website is performing in search engines. But not all metrics are useful. Some are vanity metrics - they look impressive but don’t actually translate into business growth.

A good SEO agency focuses on actionable metrics that drive traffic, engagement, and revenue. These are the numbers that truly matter when evaluating SEO success.

So, what are these key metrics? Let’s break them down.

Organic Traffic

Would you hire a fitness coach who’s never helped anyone lose weight? Probably not. The same logic applies to SEO agencies - if they aren’t growing organic traffic for their clients, they’re not doing their job.

What to look for:

• Check their clients' organic traffic growth using tools like Google Analytics, Ahrefs, or SEMrush.
• Ask: "Can you show me case studies where you’ve increased organic traffic?"
• Beware of agencies that focus on rankings but ignore traffic - just because a site ranks doesn’t mean people are actually visiting it.

Keyword Rankings

Ranking on the first page of Google is great, but are they ranking for the right keywords?

Some agencies inflate their success by ranking for low-value, easy-to-win keywords that don’t actually drive business. That’s why it’s important to analyze keyword quality, not just quantity.

What to check:

• Do they rank for high-intent keywords that actually lead to conversions?
• Are their rankings stable, or do they fluctuate dramatically?
• Ask for a list of the top money-making keywords they’ve ranked for.

Domain Authority & Backlink Quality

Ever heard the phrase, "It’s not what you know, it’s who you know?" In SEO, it’s who links to you that matters.

Backlinks - links from other websites pointing to yours - are one of the biggest ranking factors in Google’s algorithm. But not all backlinks are good.

What to ask an agency:

• How do you build backlinks? (Look for white-hat strategies, not paid links or shady link farms.)
• Can you show examples of backlinks you’ve earned for clients?
• What’s your process for removing toxic links?

Bounce Rate - Click-Through Rate (CTR) & User Engagement Metrics

Let’s say an agency helps you rank #1 for a great keyword. Sounds good, right? But what if no one actually clicks on your result?

That’s where Click-Through Rate (CTR) comes in. It measures how many people see your page in search results vs. how many actually click on it.

How to evaluate an agency:

• Do they optimize title tags and meta descriptions to improve CTR?
• Can they show a history of improving bounce rate and dwell time?
• Do they track how visitors behave on a site after they land?

SEO isn’t just about bringing people to your site - it’s about keeping them engaged once they arrive.

Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO)

Traffic is great, but at the end of the day, what really matters is conversions. Are visitors actually turning into leads or customers?

A strong SEO agency doesn’t just chase rankings. They optimize pages for user experience, calls-to-action, and lead generation.

What to look for:

• Do they A/B test landing pages to improve conversions?
• Have they helped other clients increase revenue through SEO?
• Can they show data on conversion improvements from their work?

Core Web Vitals & Page Speed Performance

Google cares about user experience, and so should your SEO agency. Slow-loading pages and clunky designs can kill your rankings, even if you have great content.

Key performance indicators:

• Page load speed (Should be under 3 seconds on mobile and desktop.)
• Mobile-friendliness (Is the site responsive and easy to use on all devices?)
• Core Web Vitals scores (Google’s measurement of page performance.)

Page loading speed is a vital metric not just from a user experience perspective, but also because it directly impacts your SEO. Slow-loading pages can lead to user frustration, increased bounce rates, and subsequently, lower rankings on search engine results pages.

Agencies that ignore page speed and user experience aren’t thinking long-term.

Therefore, it's crucial that the SEO agency you choose is proficient in technical SEO and understands the importance of optimizing page load speed. How can you assess this? You could start by asking the agency how they have improved page loading speed for their previous clients. Moreover, you can use tools like Google's PageSpeed Insights to check the load speed of their clients' websites. This tool also provides specific suggestions for improvement, which the agency should be able to address effectively. Demonstrated success in optimizing page load speed indicates an SEO agency's expertise in technical SEO, contributing to a better user experience and higher search engine rankings.

Mobile Traffic

With the steady rise in smartphone usage, mobile traffic now plays an undeniably substantial role in overall web traffic. It's become essential for your website to be optimized for mobile users, providing an excellent user experience and performing well in mobile search results.

A potential SEO agency's aptitude in enhancing websites for mobile traffic is a significant consideration. How can you check this? Ask the agency for specific examples of how they have improved mobile optimization for previous clients. You can also use tools like Google's Mobile-Friendly Test to check if their clients' sites are indeed mobile-friendly.

An agency well-versed in mobile SEO should also be adept at addressing issues like mobile page speed, responsive design, and mobile UX - key factors influencing mobile rankings and user engagement.

Local SEO Performance (If You Run a Local Business)

If you’re a local business, your SEO agency should be helping you dominate local search. That means:

• Ranking high in Google’s Local Pack (Map Listings)
• Optimizing your Google Business Profile
• Building local citations and reviews

Ask the agency for examples of local businesses they’ve helped rank in Google’s Map Pack.

Assessing an SEO Agency Using Key Metrics

A good SEO agency provides clear, detailed reports - not just vanity metrics.

What to expect from a great agency:

• Monthly reports that show traffic, rankings, backlinks, and conversions
• Insights on what’s working and what’s not
• Actionable next steps, not just generic charts and graphs

‍

Once you are familiar with these key SEO metrics, you can assess an SEO agency more effectively. Ask the agency to provide case studies or client testimonials that demonstrate their success in improving these metrics. If they have consistently helped businesses increase organic traffic, improve keyword rankings, and boost conversion rates, they can likely do the same for you.

However, remember that SEO is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The significance of different metrics can vary depending on your business goals and industry. For instance, if you run an e-commerce store, conversion rate optimization might be more crucial than if you run a blog where the goal is to keep bounce rate low and session duration high.

If an agency can’t explain their results in plain English, that’s a red flag. A reputable SEO agency will work with you to understand your business goals and identify the key metrics most relevant to you. They will then develop a customized SEO strategy aimed at improving these metrics.

The Bigger Picture: Long-Term Success

Not all agencies have your best interests at heart. Here are some warning signs:

• They promise “guaranteed rankings.” No one can guarantee rankings.
• They focus only on keyword rankings, not business results. It's crucial to choose an agency that focuses not just on short-term gains but also on long-term success.
• They don’t explain their backlink strategy. If they’re vague, they’re probably using risky tactics that might offer quick wins but can harm your website in the long run.
• They lock you into long contracts with no clear deliverables.

SEO is a long-term strategy. If something feels off, trust your gut.

While analyzing an SEO agency based on key metrics is important, it's equally important to look at the bigger picture.

They should emphasize sustainable SEO practices that provide steady growth over time. Look for an agency that values transparency and educates you about the process, so you understand what to expect.

Conclusion

Choosing an SEO agency is a big decision, but you can choose the right SEO agency by focusing on the right metrics and is an effective way to assess their potential to deliver results.

By understanding these metrics and knowing how to evaluate an agency's success in improving them, you can make a more informed decision when choosing an SEO agency. A good agency will prioritize traffic, engagement, conversions, and transparency - not just rankings.

Take your time, ask the right questions, and make sure the agency you choose is truly invested in your long-term success. After all, the success of your SEO efforts largely hinges on the expertise and skills of the agency you entrust with your website's visibility and growth.